The Forever Workshop

The Forever Workshop

Poetry

Why Your Writing is Getting Rejected | Insights From an Indie Press Editor

with Kelli Russell Agodon, poet, editor and co-founder of Two Sylvias Press

Kelli Russell Agodon's avatar
The Forever Workshop's avatar
Kelli Russell Agodon and The Forever Workshop
Aug 26, 2026
∙ Paid

Hey friends,

Welcome to another edition of Tell Us Something We Don’t Know… where we ask our favorite literary experts about their specialist subject.

Today, we're talking about the submissions process for indie presses with someone who has experience on both sides of the literary curtain…

Our Expert:

Kelli Russell Agodon (she/her) is a bi/queer poet, editor, book cover designer, and co-founder of Two Sylvias Press.

Two Sylvias Press is an independent press located in the Seattle area that publishes poetry, memoir, essays, books on the craft of writing, and creativity tools, including the bestselling resource for poets, The Weekly Muse.


Paid subscribers get access to the full archive and all new lessons!

The Takeaways:

  • Why the selection process is just as hard for editors as it is for writers!

  • The subjective reasons your work might be turned down (that has nothing to do with its quality)

  • How to deal with rejection (without catastrophizing)

  • Submission red flags to avoid

  • And how to make your poetry collection as strong as it can be

By the end of this Q&A, you'll have some new insights on the submissions process at an indie press, hopefully feel a little less angsty about sending your poetry collections out there!

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Forever Workshop to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Kelli Russell Agodon's avatar
A guest post by
Kelli Russell Agodon
Poet. Paddleboarder. Easygoing Capricorn. New book alert: Accidental Devotions (2026) @CopperCanyonPrs / Editor @TwoSylviasPress / Faculty @PLU_RWW she/her⚤🏳️‍🌈
Subscribe to Kelli
© 2026 Chill Subs · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture